What is the Truth about American Muslims, Part 2 / 3

The First Amendment Center, the Muslim Brotherhood and assorted leftists at the Interfaith Alliance have produced a polished piece of apologist propaganda for Islam. It has been getting a lot media play, because it says all the things the public would like to believe about Islam. It is a textbook summary of arguments made by Islam’s apologists and serves as a teaching example of how to refute this propaganda using the scientific method.

Here is the truth about Muslims. They will not tell you the whole truth, but only a half truth. Islam is inherently dualistic and holds two opposing truths at the same time. There are two Korans, an early Koran written in Mecca and a later Koran written in Medina. There is no jihad in the early Meccan Koran, but the later Medinan Koran is filled with jihad. So which is the real Islam? Both peace and war are true Islam. A Muslim will only talk about the half he needs. But, there is one Muslim who will tell you the complete truth—Mohammed. Needless to say, this propaganda does not consult him.

Here is the second part of the analysis:

9. How do American Muslims participate in American public life?

American Muslims have created institutions of their own in the United States, just like other religious communities. There are many long-established groups such as the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA), an umbrella organization of some 300 mosques and Islamic centers based in Indiana, and newer organizations like the Council for the Advancement of Muslim Professionals.

“Islamic Society of North America (ISNA)”

Whoa! ISNA is participation in American life? ISNA is pure Muslim Brotherhood; in fact, they are at the top of the list in the Muslim Brotherhood memo submitted in the Holy Land Foundation trial. And what is the Muslim Brotherhood? An organization dedicated to bringing the caliphate to rule over the entire world and to destroy our Constitution by replacing it with Sharia law.

And remember the Muslim Brotherhood motto? Here it is:

“Allah is our objective. The Prophet is our leader. The Qur’an is our law. Jihad is our way. Dying in the way of Allah is our highest hope.”

ISNA and all other Muslim Brotherhood types participate in American life in the sense of working to annihilate it.

10. Is Islam a political movement?

No. Islam is a religious tradition and adherents to Islam are called Muslim. Of course, American Muslims like Americans from other religious groups, participate in American political life. American Muslim voting patterns generally mirror the broader American population. American Muslims are Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians, liberals, and conservatives. There is no one political platform or agenda for those who practice the religion of Islam in the United States.

“Islam is a religious tradition”

Yes, but it is also a political tradition. To prove that read the Sira, the biography of Mohammed. It is very interesting to plot the data found in the Sira about how Islam grew. Here is the plot:

The religion of Islam was a failure. In preaching the religion of Islam, Mohammed converted 150 Arabs to Islam. Then he went to Medina and became a politician and a jihadist. During the last 9 years of his life in Medina, he averaged an event of violence on the average of every 6 weeks. When Mohammed died every Arab was a Muslim. Without politics and jihad there would have never been an Islam. The religion failed, the politics succeeded.

11. Have American Muslim leaders spoken out against extremist violence?

Yes. Many American Muslim leaders and organizations have repeatedly denounced extremist violence in the strongest possible terms.

Of the many statements and actions taken by American Muslims to condemn and counter terrorism, the fatwa (religious ruling) from the Fiqh Council of North America (an Islamic juristic body) captures the views of the vast majority of American Muslims: “Islam strictly condemns religious extremism and the use of violence against innocent lives. There is no justification in Islam for extremism or terrorism.”

Fiqh Council of North America condems violence, but Islam does not condemn jihad. Jihad is neither extremism nor terrorism. The Fiqh Council of North America (a Muslim Brotherhood group) may condemn terrorism, but Allah does not.

8:12 God revealed His will to the angels, saying: ‘I shall be with you. Give courage to the believers. I shall cast terror into the hearts of the Kafirs. Strike off their heads, strike off the very tips of their fingers!’

“innocent lives”

As you read about innocence, remember that a Kafir is in perpetual rebellion against Islam. Hence, Kafirs are never innocent, but guilty of offending Allah.

The Fiqh Council of North America’s statement affirms the following Islamic principles:

All acts of terrorism, including those targeting the life and property of civilians, whether perpetrated by suicidal or any other form of attacks, are haram (forbidden) in Islam.

“All acts of terrorism…are haram”

Well, so acts of terror are forbidden in Islam. But jihad is a community obligation for all Muslims. Jihad is not terror, but sacred violence to prepare the world for Islam and the Sharia.

Koran 2:216 You are commanded to fight although you dislike it. You may hate something that is good for you, and love something that is bad for you. Allah knows and you do not.

“It is haram (forbidden) for a Muslim to cooperate with any individual or group that is involved in any act of terrorism or prohibited violence.”

I guess that Mohammed did not get this memo, because he said, just the opposite:

[Bukhari 4,52,96] Mohammed: “Anyone who arms a jihadist is rewarded just as a fighter would be; anyone who gives proper care to a holy warrior’s dependents is rewarded just as a fighter would be.”

“It is the civic and religious duty of Muslims to undertake full measures to protect the lives of all civilians, and ensure the security and well-being of fellow citizens.”

Muslims are to undertake full measures to follow the Sunna of Mohammed and he attacked every single neighbor, without a single exception. And he did it year after year, until he ran out of enemies in Arabia and then he left Arabia to go to Syria and attack the Christians there.

12. Are American Muslims concerned about extremist violence in the United States?

Yes. Most American Muslims, like most other Americans, are deeply concerned about the problem of extremist violence committed in the name of Islam. According to the most reliable data we have, the overwhelming majority of American Muslims is well integrated into American society and report criminal activity. Over the past decade, 40% of domestic terrorism plots have been uncovered or deterred with assistance from American Muslims.[iii]

“40% of domestic terrorism plots have been uncovered or deterred with assistance from American Muslims”

Since 100% of the domestic jihad has been by Muslims, what can be said about the other 60%? What Muslims did not turn them in?

13. Do American Muslim leaders support freedom of expression and religious liberty?

“support freedom of expression and religious liberty”

Really? Then why do the Muslim Brotherhood organizations demand that only Muslims be allowed to talk about Islam to government officials? That is freedom of expression? Under pressure of Islamic leaders, no US agency can listen to a lecture about Islam if it is given by Kafirs, courtesy of Obama.

Yes. Many American Muslim leaders, educational institutions, and advocacy groups have repeatedly spoken out for freedom of expression and are actively involved in promoting religious liberty for all people both in the United States and abroad.

“promoting religious liberty for all people both in the United States and abroad”

The Center for the Study of Political Islam publishes a monthly newsletter called the Bulletin of Christian Persecution. It documents the murder, rape, kidnapping of Christians in Muslim nations. Thousands of Christians, Buddhists, and Hindus die each year at the hands of Muslims. This persecution was started 1400 years ago by Mohammed and sanctioned by Allah. Here is the liberty promised by Allah:

Koran 9:29 Fight against such of those to whom the Scriptures were given [Christians] as believe in neither Allah nor the Last Day, who do not forbid what Allah and His apostles have forbidden [follow Sharia], and do not embrace Islam, until they pay the dhimmi tax out of hand and are utterly humiliated.

Allah’s liberty for Christians includes murder until the survivors agree to live by the Sharia, pay special taxes and are humiliated.

Misunderstood terms and practices

14. What does “jihad” mean? Isn’t it a “holy war?”

“Jihad” literally means striving, or doing one’s utmost. Within Islam, there are two basic theological understandings of the word: The “Greater Jihad,” is the struggle against the lower self – the struggle to purify one’s heart, do good, avoid evil, and make oneself a better person. The “Lesser Jihad” is an outward struggle. Jihad constitutes a moral principle to struggle against any obstacle that stands in the way of the good. Bearing, delivering, and raising a child, for example, is an example of outward jihad, because of the many obstacles that must be overcome to deliver and raise the child successfully. Jihad may also involve fighting against oppressors and aggressors who commit injustice. It is not “holy war” in the way a crusade would be considered a holy war, and while Islam allows and even encourages proselytizing, it forbids forced conversion. In Islamic tradition, the form of jihad that involves fighting requires specific ethical conditions under which it is permissible to fight, as well as clear rules of engagement such as the requirement to protect non-combatants. Scholars have likened Jihad as fighting to the Christian concept of “just war.”

“The “Greater Jihad,” is the struggle against the lower self – the struggle to purify one’s heart, do good, avoid evil, and make oneself a better person. The “Lesser Jihad” is an outward struggle.”

Let us measure the truth of this statement. The Hadith are the Traditions of Mohammed and are part of the Sunna. The Koran says 91 times that Mohammed is the perfect Muslim and every Muslim is to model their life after him. The prime text for Hadith is by Bukhari. If you count the number of hadiths devoted to jihad, they account for 21% of the total, roughly 1400 traditions about jihad. If you go through these hadiths, less than 2% of them are about the greater jihad. That means that 98% of them are about the lesser jihad of killing Kafirs.

That means that the greater jihad is statistically insignificant. Jihad is about the annihilation of Kafirs, said another way, “an outward struggle”.

“it forbids forced conversion”

This implies that there is some sort of “convert or die” situation with Islam. But Islam has always been about death and other religions. For instance according to Sharia law and the Koran, a Muslim is not supposed to kill another Muslim. Not so with Kafirs. Mohammed killed Kafirs repeatedly. First he started killing and robbing pagans. Then he started killing Jews. Next he attacked the Christians. So it may not be convert or die, but it is “convert and you won’t die”.

When Mohammed died Abu Bakr, his closest Companion, became caliph. His first order of business was to go to war against all Arabs who wanted to leave Islam, the Apostasy war. Apostasy is a capital crime in the Sharia. Leave Islam and you can die.

The variety of interpretations of Lesser

Jihad or just war over 1400 years in many settings is a complex discussion.

Much of the contemporary misuse of the term “jihad” may be dated to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, when stateless actors began to claim the right to declare jihad. In Islamic tradition, there is no theological or political basis for this claim. Radical and extremist groups appropriate and misuse the term “jihad” to give a religious veneer to their violent political movements and tactics.

“Jihad or just war over 1400 years in many settings is a complex discussion.”

Actually, the results of jihad over the last 1400 years are very simple. Look at the Tears of Jihad, the totals of different social groups who were murdered.

Tears of Jihad
Africans 120
Hindus 80
Christians 60
Buddhists 10
Total 270

Jihad is not a fringe doctrine with a verse or two. Islam has 3 sacred texts—Koran, Sira (Mohammed’s biography) and Hadith (Traditions). Look at how much of them are about jihad.

The reason that there is so much material about jihad in the later Koran is that it was responsible for the success of Islam.

Another part of the discussion about jihad is that the Koran and the Sharia demand that part of the obligatory Muslim tax, the zakat, must go to those fighting in Allah’s cause, jihad. Jihad has a budget in the Koran and the Sharia.

16. Are Muslim men allowed to marry four wives?

While the Qur’an sanctions marriage to up to four wives (Q 4:3), the wording of the verse is understood by some Muslim scholars to allow but at the same time discourage marrying more than one wife. Verse 4:3 says that a Muslim man may marry up to four wives if he can treat them equally. Since men cannot treat any two people equally, the practice which was historically acceptable during times of crisis, like war, is now even outlawed in some Muslim majority nations.

The short answer is yes. Yes, according to the Koran. Yes, according to the Sharia. So that means that it is sacred law and when enough Islamists come to power in a country, polygamy will return. What the Sharia allows is the Pole Star that Islam will revolve around.

From the Sharia: m6.10 It is unlawful for a free man to marry more than four women. It is fitter to confine oneself to just one.

Part 3 next…

Bill Warner, Director, Center for the Study of Political Islam
Permalink: https://politicalislam.com/what-is-the-truth-about-american-muslims-part-2-3/
Copyright © 2012 CBSX, LLC, politicalislam.com
Use as needed, just give credit and do not edit.

5 Responses

  1. A muslim Convert

    To Carl..

    From the way you wrote about your ex- pious muslim… I think after 6 years you still recalled this incidents shows that you are guilty of the highest order.

    The great Arab distance from you becasue he feel sorry for you that you cannot see his point that is pure and correct while your xtain nonsense of trinity or 3 god in one person is utter crap… He stayed away from you ike all muslim will do and me too is becasue we are afraid that you may corrupt our thoughts.. Our koran and hadith is the final and complete word of god..

    Please be well infomred that CANADA has 30 million people and Islam being a religion that expand thru baby boomers will be the majority by 30 years time and hope you and are alive….i suggest you let your kids be muslim so that when we are majoirty and vote change your westernern culture to ARABIC..your kids will be safe…..It is the USA..The LAST battle ground between Muslima and the Free world shall be fought… We muslim are winning day by day…..CANADA are run by Liberals….A distance cousins oif UK….

    ABOUT this questions ..Christians and Islamists war….All muslim are taught to be on the Muslim sides when a muslim have to choose sides..This is stupid questions to asked any muslim….Fort Hood masscare rings a bell..?

    John Walker ring a bell..Then why do all muslima from china to indonesia..yearn to fight in Middle east and for AL queda….Let this be clear…

    In any way bewteen a Muslim and Kafirs…Support the Jihadist aka Muslim…We do not want to be question by ALLAH on judgenebnt day when ALLAH pose this questions..Why as a MUSLIM..did you side witht the KAFIRS…? That would be an APOSATE and a murtaq goes to hell…
    So your Arab is being a true Muslim and don’t asked the obvious to a Muslim if you want to keep the firendshiip..Let me tell you about how to gain firends with muslim…Be a liberals and be like Obama…bow down and appease to all Muslim wants and rants and be on their sides.eg..Anti -zionist..Curse the jews and xztains..Support SHARIAH LAW….I mean support any thing MUSLIM against KAFIR..agianst war in iraq, aghansitan…etc..Be like BBC..be like RT..Be like OBAMA and democrates and support anythihg ISLAM in the name of diversity…

    I suggest you leran from Tariq Ramadan, John Eposito and Karren Armstong and Lauren Booth and Yusef estefs and CAT stevens…Sean Stone..and the greatest of all NEIL Armstrong..Who heard the islamic prayer called on the moon and convert to ISLAM…Not even Mohd Ali come close….Please read more KORAN and Haidth…I reccomnen koran 8 VERSE 12..A beautiful verse that will once and for all convinced you to be a MUSLIM..

  2. Carl

    I have been studying Islam for quite some time now. My Arab/Canadian friend tried to convert me (a Protestant Christian) so I spent much time reading the English version of the Quran and then discussing issues with my friend. I lost his friendship when I challanged him about me the imbicile, worthy of death. His claim was he would never go there with me, his friend; but when asked if war was declared between Christians and Islamists on which side he would stand. He couldn’t or wouldn’t answer so I accepted that as my answer and told him I was not impressed. He has not spoken to me since. That is about 6 years and counting.
    Islam at it’s best.

  3. Hellbat44

    What is the point of making a comment if it is not going to be posted in a timely manner!?

  4. Ralph

    Recently, I watched a year-2002 two-hour-long VHS video documentary that I borrowed from the public library — “Muhammad, Legacy of a Prophet.” I watched it twice. It was calm and flowing and gave an impression of peace. It had presumably been broadcasted on TV, although I hadn’t seen it there.

    The video talked a bit about the many Muslim people who had settled in Dearborn, Michigan after some of them had presumably fled from the Middle East. There were also other vignettes presented about the lives of Muslim people in America.

    What I saw was a peaceful, golden-rule-driven Islam being practiced in America. Shown was a purportedly Muslim-started-and-operated soup kitchen which purportedly fed mostly non-Muslim people.

    What the video portrayed about Muhammad’s life was nearly all sweetness and light. It was clearly heavily-whitewashed for public consumption. Everything that Muhammad did seemed to be justified or else downplayed by the set of narrators.

    The many people who glowingly spoke and testified in the video were typically not being realistic about Muhammad. They were woefully ignorant about the real Muhammad, or they were deliberately whitewashing him, or they were unconsciously in denial about the real Muhammad. In the approximately ten years since the video was made, some of them might have become enlightened.

    That presumably-broadcasted video helps to explain why the general public is confused by anti-jihad statements. There is a mental disconnect between the sweetness-and-light version of Muhammad that presumably appeared on TV and the facts about Muhammad that are presented by anti-jihad people in other media.

    The video that I watched contained too much heavily-whitewashed information about Muhammad himself to allow it to be broadcasted on TV to the public without a disclaimer. It did a disservice to the cause of anti-jihad in America.

    Such videos should be broadcasted with a disclaimer … “This video tells a story about a historical character and may contain speculative information or propaganda. Please do your own independent research to validate or invalidate the content of this video.”

    If by some miracle, a video portraying the real life of Muhammad were to be broadcasted on TV without ensuing violence, it would not be initially believed by the general public, because there has already been too much propaganda presented about the false Muhammad. However, some people might be spurred to resolve their mental disconnects by doing their own research to learn the truth.

  5. Hellbat44


    Muslim suicide bombers worldwide may be set to begin a three-day prayer strike this coming Monday in an unprecedented dispute over the number of virgins they are entitled to in the afterlife… Islamic Paradise.

    The unrest began last Tuesday when Al Qaeda announced, in a fatwa, that the number of virgins a suicide bomber would be entitled to after their glorious martyrdom would be cut by 25%, effective immediately, from 72 to 54. An Al Qaeda spokesman, speaking on behalf of Allah himself, said increases in recent years in the number of suicide bombings has resulted in a shortage of virgins in Paradise.

    The Islamic suicide bombers’ union, the Koran Approved Business Organization of Occupational Martyrs (KABOOM), responded with a statement saying the move was unacceptable to its members and called for a prayer strike vote. General Secretary Abdullah Amir told the Islamic press, “Our members are literally working themselves to death in the cause of Jihad and we don’t ask for much in return but to be treated like this is a real “kick in the teeth.” Emergency talks between KABOOM and Al Qaeda have so far failed to produce an acceptable agreement and it appears the prayer strike will go on as planned starting Monday morning. To restate organization policy, membership to KABOOM is limited to male martyrs only, NOT second class Muslim females, who are encouraged to stay home and give birth to martyr replacements.

    Speaking from his cave in an undisclosed location, Al Qaeda chief executive Haisheet Mapants explained, “I sympathize with our martyrs concerns but Allah is simply not in a position to meet their demands at this time. Would be Muslim martyrs are simply not accepting the realities of modern-day Jihad in a competitive marketplace. Thanks to increasing Western depravity, there is now a chronic shortage of virgins in Paradise. It’s a straight choice between reducing the number of virgins or laying our martyrs off…the choice is theirs. I don’t like cutting benefits but I’d hate to have to be the one to tell thousands of martyrs that they won’t be able to blow themselves up. The only good news for martyrs is that Allah would still provide all other standard perks such as a personal cameo appearance with him personally, Persian carpets, nubile little boys, and all the milk and honey they can drink”for eternity. So, on the whole, things could be much worse declared Haisheet Mapants.

    Spokespersons for KABOOM stated that the change would not hurt their membership significantly because would be martyrs have recently won a negotiated settlement with Allah that allows them to groom and rape underage Kafir girls while still on Earth – which everyone can agree is a pretty good perk to their existing Islamic pre-martyrdom benefits package.

Leave a Reply

We require registration to prevent excessive automated spam commenting.